Monday, January 25, 2010

Board Game Review - Talisman 4th Edition

I'm a little surprised at myself that I even played Talisman again. After I played the third edition, I swore I would rather scrub grout than play any version of the game. But then I wound up with a copy of the Black Industries edition, and since so many people insisted that the new one was better, I thought it had to be worth one more try.

They were right - fourth edition is better. But I'm still not sure I would call this a great game.

Several things have changed from third edition to fourth. The most obvious would be the character selection. (Well, maybe not the most obvious - the art in third edition looks like it was created by a pimply 15-year-old who spent all his time drawing skulls all over his mother's photo albums, and the art in fourth edition is brilliant. But I'll get to that.) Instead of a bunch of stock Warhammer characters played with sculpts that were leftover after they made Warhammer Quest, fourth edition has a whole bunch of human characters, just a couple monsters, one elf and one dwarf. Now the characters make a lot more sense, which is nice because I found it questionable that a skaven would be as competitive as a dwarven berserker.

The new special powers also feel like they're good for something, which is another edge over fourth edition. The prophetess has a great ability where she can have a little control over what she encounters when she draws a card, the minstrel can charm an animal companion, and the sorceress can steal followers from the other players. None of the characters feels as completely useless as a few of the guys in third edition, which is especially good if you're drawing your characters at random.

Fighting stuff hasn't changed, but the stuff you fight has. There are a lot more non-combat encounters in the adventure deck now, which kind of sucks if you're trying to kill stuff so you can get enough power to win the game, but is kind of cool if you just want to wander around a rectangular world and meet weird things. But seriously, this is also an improvement, because some of those nonviolent cards will help you get powered up even better than killing things (although wholesale slaughter is still a viable option).

The end game is completely different. Where third edition has you flipping over cards and throwing away your crap on the way to fight the big bad guy, the new one has a series of difficult encounters that are likely to slow you way down if you're not completely ready. And once you get to the very middle, you don't have a one-round bruhaha for all the marbles - you have to use the crown of command to kill everyone else, and if you roll as badly as I did, this can take a while.

In fact, the end of the game is arguably the best improvement over third edition (unless you count the teen-angst skateboard art). Because you need some time to kill everybody, there's a point in the game where one guy gets close to the front doors of the inner region, and suddenly everyone scrambles to get there, too. It's not like third edition, where the barbarian gets to the middle and two minutes later you're putting away the game. Instead, there's an sudden, intense competition to scramble over each other in a mad attempt to save yourself from oblivion. The guy who gets to the crown first has an edge, but it's not ironclad - in fact, there's every possibility that the first character to the crown still might not win.

But possibly the most important change, in my opinion, is that the game no longer looks like an 80's metal band album cover. The art in this edition is gorgeous and evocative. Where third edition makes you wonder if the art was created by a half-sober tattoo artist, fourth edition makes you want to play just because it's so damned good-looking. The characters are on cardboard standups instead of plastic miniatures, but I actually prefer that because that means they're in color. I don't have time to paint every plastic figure that ever came with a board game, so even when I'm playing games I really love, I frown at the fact that everyone is gray.

Now, several things have not changed. You still have virtually no control over where you land. You still have almost no control over winning or losing fights. You still have a country shaped like a double bed, and you still have the same thoroughly arbitrary paths to victory. The basic flaws of third edition are still here - a remarkable lack of meaningful decisions being one of them, and a game that seems to be ruled by the dice rather than your ability to outplay your opponents. If you're a snobby game nerd who thinks the best player has to win every time, you're going to hate Talisman, no matter what edition you're playing. But if you want a meandering adventure game with some cool interaction and gorgeous art, you might really dig the hell out of the new Talisman.

Now that I've played a version of Talisman that wasn't totally lame, I can see why people over the age of ten would actually want to play it. I can't say that it will be my first pick - I've got like twenty or thirty games I like better - but for an evening of light, adventurous gaming entertainment, I'll drag it out now and then. I wouldn't play third edition if you held an acetylene torch to my feet (unless you light it, then I'll play anything you want), but this new Talisman might just hit my table again.


Really nice art
New rules add a few more interesting decisions
Better characters and fewer wasted turns

Still almost all luck
Still a lot like Candyland with magic swords
All things considered, Runebound is still way more fun

I don't know if the Fantasy Flight version of Talisman is the same as the Black Industries version, but whatever, Dogstar's got it anyway. If you want a light fantasy adventure game, you could do a lot worse:


Anonymous said...

it seems it's just me, but I like 3rd edition art (that in fact, is by the same author of Blood Bowl art).

also, I like more the quick end of third edition, than the drag-on of the 2nd and 4th, as the game is just too long for what it offers even without the boring end.

anyway, it's a game that had a sense in mid 80s when it was first released. there's no meaning in playing it today, unless you're too stoned to play anything else...


Unknown said...

The newest version is the Fantasy Flight Games version, which is also temporarily out of print. They tell us here at Dogstar Games it should be back in print in less than a month (February 2010).


Pete, Matt's Soulmate said...

The FFG version is the best, hands-down, and when you consider the expansions Frostmarch and Dungeon (the Reaper one is as gay as Elvis is dead...) it is, in totality, better than any other version.

I love this game. Yes, it's lame, repetitive, and the roll-n-move is kind-of a bitch, but it's fun, doesn't take forever (usually) and is great if you have the kind of wife that sees gaming with you as a reward for changing shitty diapers and 'licking the kitty' from time to time. It's not Twilight Imperium, but it's a far sight better than watching "The Singing Bee" with the wife for "bonding time".

I'm surprised you're not more into this game, Matt, since you like Adventurers. It's the same concept: run, get shit, get out.

R Singers said...

Third edition of Talisman was awful. The second edition was much better. The best way to play Talisman has always been to play while drinking copious amounts of alcohol with your friends.

haslo said...

Doh, now you looked at a new version, and you ended up with the one just one version before one where you have a little more control over where you land :P

The revised 4th edition (the FFG version) has way less printing errors, a better manual, and introduces the concept of fate. Every character has a different number of fate tokens from the start, with various mechanics of getting fate back mostly in the adventure cards. Spending a fate token lets you reroll a die. So when you really want to roll a three, you at least have two attempts for that.

I'm writing this because it gives the player slightly more control again.

Still, the game depends a lot on luck. I see it more as a journey through a land of fantasy, where I'm looking at the pretty pictures. And it's not really my favourite game, either. But it's definitely very nice to look at :P

savsuns said...

Explore your options for healthy aging. Find research and information on the health benefits of resveratrol, the miracle polyphenol found in red wine and its miraculous antiaging benefits. Resveratrol research suggests it has antiaging, anti-inflammatory, anti-cancer, anti-oxidant, and cardiovascular benefits. cheap medicine

buy lasix said...

Very good customer service, prompt delivery (lol...prompt for coming from so far away!), and good products. I recommend this company to my friends all the time. is a godsend to those of us without medical insurance.